Calling for a fundamental cultural shift through stories (with a side of your favorite brew)

The Seep by Chana Porter, a Book Review

A beautiful and thought provoking speculative fiction about aliens and a gentle invasion of earth

—Amanda Khong, Bookish Brews

Bookish Brews Snapshot

The Seep by Chana Porter

In the wake of the softest alien invasion ever, everyone seems to have embraced The Seep with open arms. Except for Trina, who is reluctant to change, and it seems to be putting unwanted attention on her.

👽 Aliens 💫 Atmospheric 📖 Couldn't Put It Down 🤔 Thought Provoking

Book Review

weird, mildly creepy, magically wonderful, confusing, thoughtful

The Seep was one that really has stuck with me for a while since I read it almost 2 months ago. I just can’t stop thinking about the idea of a slow invasion such as this. It was so creepy how accepting we were of this. If we had an alien invasion of a creature that seemed to have a symbiotic relationship with us, would we just accept them?

Trina is a trans woman who seems to be the only one on the planet who has rejected the soft, gentle, but still world-changing alien invasion. The Seep claims to be a symbiotic relationship with humans, but Trina is reluctant to submit to the change. In a world where capitalism has fallen, barriers are broken down, and anything you can imagine is possible, Trina struggles with what the meaning of life is anymore.

The Seep was one of the highlights of my end-of-year reads. At the moment, I definitely enjoyed the book, but what really makes me love this book is the fact that it has stayed with me. Since I’ve read it, I’ve thought about this book, or even referenced it quite a few times. It has so many things in it that make you think. It is so relevant to the world today in the weirdest possible way. It is really a stunning book. The way that humans just accept something that isn’t explicitly harmful to them, and the way that we ostracize someone for not quite accepting a new normal so easily, and the way both of those were portrayed in the book so seamlessly.

It’s hard to say anything without giving the entire book away because it is not full of twists and turns. Rather, it is full of harrowing moments of pure humanity. It questions what we think of as love. It begs us to think about what it means to be who we are, together, as humans. It was heartbreaking, hopeful, weird, interesting, and wonderful. In exactly the same way life is.

Book Club Questions: The Seep

  • Do you think if this were to happen in our world that people would react similarly to those in the books? If not, how would they act differently? Would we really accept an alien species into the world if they seemed to be symbiotic?
  • How does this book test your perception of what is considered love? How did you feel about Deeba’s decision to change her life? Which side of the argument were you on? Can you see the other side of the argument? Discuss how this challenges your perception of romantic love vs. familial love.
  • How did you feel about the decision to present yourself as someone who has passed away? Did you find it respectful or disrespectful? Can you see the other side of the argument? Discuss.
Picture of Chana Porter

Chana Porter

Chana Porter is a novelist, playwright, teacher, MacDowell fellow, and cofounder of The Octavia Project, a STEM and writing program for girls and trans and nonbinary youth that uses speculative fiction to envision greater possibilities for our world.

Share this post:

Decolonize Your Bookshelf With Me

Hi! I’m Amanda. Bookish Brews started as a personal project to decolonize my bookshelf turned into a passion for diverse stories. Once I realized how much we can grow personally from stories by people with different experiences than our own, I realized how much they impact our world. But I also know that growth from stories does not happen without intentionality. Bookish Brews is dedicated to building meaningful conversations about how stories by diverse voices can change our lives, our culture, and our world.

"Let's change the system via the lens of compelling fiction."

Behind the Scenes

Subscribe to my newsletter to get deeper about stories, art, culture, and our place within it all

Or read the archives before subscribing

Let's Be Friends

Support Bookish Brews

Bookish Brews is a literature website that exclusively works with writers, creatives, and people from systematically marginalized communities with a focus on the global majority. If you appreciate what we do here, please consider stopping by our Support Page

Meet the Founder